FJR Ingeniería Termomecánica
Back to projects Food machinery in Colombia

Thermal assessment of a continuous cooker

An immersion cooker heated with thermal oil was delivering product cooked on the outside and raw in the center. We found the root cause and defined how to fix it without redesigning the equipment.

Service
Process equipment assessment
Throughput
1,000 kg/h
Target
75 °C at the center
Available time
16 minutes

The challenge

The equipment cooks the product submerged in water at 92 °C, heated by a thermal oil jacket at 240 °C, while two stainless steel conveyor belts carry it along the tank.

With the previous basket system the product cooked well. Once the conveyor belts were added, it started coming out cooked on the outside and raw in the center, a quality and food safety problem. The manufacturer needed to know why, and whether the current oil flow configuration or the alternative under evaluation was better.

What we did

  1. Physical diagnosis. We identified the chain of thermal resistances in series that governs the process: oil, jacket wall, tank water, product surface and product center. This let us rank where the bottleneck was before calculating in detail.
  2. System characterization. Thermophysical properties of the product, water, oil and steel, with geometry taken from the fabrication drawing.
  3. Heat transfer coefficients at each interface, using correlations suited to the actual flow regime: Dittus-Boelter, Churchill-Chu, Churchill-Bernstein and Rohsenow.
  4. Steady-state and transient energy balances of the tank and the oil circuit.
  5. Transient conduction in the product, solving the heat equation in a cylinder for different diameters and bath conditions.
  6. Comparison of the two oil flow configurations: out-and-back (V1) and cross-flow (V2).

What we found

Power was not the problem. The jacket can deliver 253.7 kW and the process needs 63.6 kW: four times more than required. The fault was in how that heat reached the product.

  1. The belt's solid guide plate blocks water circulation. The channel the product travels through becomes almost stagnant, and the convection coefficient drops from 1,117 to 140 W/m²K: eight times less heat delivered.
  2. The top 49 mm of the channel sit above the jacket and get no side heating. The water in the channel is between 75 and 88 °C, not the 92 °C design value.
  3. The product's interior is the dominant resistance (Biot number between 5.6 and 23.1). That physical limit cannot be removed, but it can be managed through piece size and better convection.
Tank cross-section, to scale Water temperature 75 °C96 °C Thermal oil jacket at 240 °C Wall without jacket Product channel: 75–88 °C Open zone: 92–96 °C water circulates but hits the plate 1 2 3 411 mm water level 322 mm upper belt 273 mm top of the jacket 223 mm solid guide plate 0 mm tank bottom 49 mm unheated
Scaled diagram prepared by FJR from the equipment dimensions. The numbers match the three findings above. The light center of each piece is the area that was not cooking through.

Results

With the current design, the center of a 40 mm piece needs 26 to 33 minutes to reach 75 °C, while the equipment only gives it 16. Combining three improvements without major structural changes brings the time down to 13.5 to 15.8 minutes, meeting the target without losing production capacity.

Minutes for the center to reach 75 °C (40 mm piece) 010203040 Current designWith improvements 16 min available 26–33 min13.5–15.8 min
The combined improvements are opening up the guide plate, sorting the product by size and raising the bath temperature.
CriterionV1: out-and-backV2: cross-flow
Heat available in the jacket232.6 kW253.7 kW (+9 %)
Temperature difference along the bath~8 °C~2 °C
Water temperature at the outlet~86 °C~91 °C
Risk of a cold zone at one endHighLow
Product center at 16 min~67 °C~69 °C

The cross-flow configuration (V2) was better on every criterion and was recommended as the final design.

Improvement plan

In order of priority, based on impact on cooking, cost and lead time:

  1. Perforate or replace the guide plate with at least 40 % open area.
  2. Sort the product to a maximum diameter of 35 mm before it enters the equipment.
  3. Lower the bottom belt so the whole channel sits within the jacket zone.
  4. Install internal water recirculation to eliminate dead zones.
  5. Raise the bath temperature to 95–97 °C.
  6. Insulate the oil piping and add a lid with steam extraction; today they release 7.7 kW into the work area.
  7. Adopt configuration V2 and review the oil set point: the process needs about 170 °C, not 240 °C.

Deliverables

  • Technical report in PDF with methodology, assumptions, calculations and results.
  • Root cause diagnosis with quantitative indicators.
  • Technical comparison of the two configurations.
  • Prioritized improvement plan and follow-up meeting.

Is your equipment not reaching process temperature?

Send us the drawing and operating conditions. We will help you find the cause before you build more units.

Request a consultation